Video: GCSE Physics Foundation Tier Pack 1 • Paper 1 • Question 8

GCSE Physics Foundation Tier Pack 1 • Paper 1 • Question 8


Video Transcript

A man is replacing an incandescent light bulb in his house with a more energy-efficient LED light. Before he changes the light bulb, he switches off the mains electricity in his house. Why does he do this?

The idea here is that this man has an operating incandescent bulb that he wants to switch out with a higher-efficiency LED light. One option for making the change would simply be to unscrew the incandescent bulb while its plugged in and lit up and then screw in the higher-efficiency LED to be done with the switch.

But instead, what he does is goes to the mains circuit breaker in his house and shuts off the mains electricity so that this light bulb, along with all the other electrical appliances in the house, turns off. It’s only then that the man goes over to the now-turned-off incandescent bulb, unscrews it, and replaces it with the LED. And the question we want to answer is, why does he do it this way?

Well, think about the socket that these two light bulbs will be screwed in to. If we look at the base of that socket, we see where the end of the light bulb electrically connects to a live wire in the wall. It’s this live wire which delivers the electricity, which in normal operation is able to light up the light bulb. And typically, this is a safe situation because the light bulb is covering up the live wire. Nothing else can get in contact with it, unless we remove the light bulb and expose this live wire. That’s of course what happens when we change a light bulb.

If, while we were changing the bulb, we accidentally touch that live connection with our finger, we would be delivered a painful electric shock. That’s of course if the mains electricity to the house is on. But if we turn them off, then there’s no danger of being shocked as we change the bulb. This then is the reason why the man changes the bulb the way that he does.

We can write it out like this. We can say that if the man does not switch off the mains electricity, then if he accidentally touches the live wire while changing the bulb, he will receive an electric shock. So it’s about personal safety. That’s why the man changes the bulb this way. Moving on, let’s look a bit now into light bulb performance.

The incandescent light bulb that the man is replacing had an efficiency of just 2.7 percent. The incandescent light bulb had a power rating of 150 watts. The equation that relates the efficiency of an electrical device to its useful power output and its total power input is efficiency is equal to useful power output divided by total power input. Calculate the useful power output of the incandescent light bulb. Give your answer to two significant figures.

We can start on our solution to this question by creating a bit of a shorthand way of writing out this equation for efficiency. We can replace efficiency with the letter capital 𝐸. We can write UPO in place of useful power output. And we can write TPI in place of total power input.

Clearing some space on screen then, here’s how we can now write this equation. We can write that the efficiency of an electrical device is equal to its useful power output divided by its total power input.

Now in our case, we want to solve for the useful power output of this incandescent light bulb. That means that, starting with this equation, we want to rearrange it algebraically so that UPO is on one side by itself. Here’s how we’d do that. If we multiply both sides of this equation by the total power input, TPI, then notice, on the right-hand side of this equation, that term appears in both the numerator and the denominator, and so it cancels out. And this means we now have a useful equation for the useful power output. It’s equal to the total power input multiplied by the efficiency of our electrical device. So for our incandescent light bulb, what is our efficiency and what is the total power input?

Our problem statement tells us that the incandescent light bulb has a power rating of 150 watts. That means that’s how much power it takes in in order to operate normally. And then as far as efficiency, we’re told that that’s equal to 2.7 percent, meaning that 2.7 percent of the total power input is actually converted to useful power output.

Notice that this tells us that almost 97 percent of the power input isn’t useful power. In the case of our bulb, it goes to heating the environment rather than lighting it. In any case, this is the efficiency of our bulb. But when we enter it into the equation, we’re not going to enter it in as a percent as it’s written. Instead, we’ll enter it in as a decimal value.

Now what is 2.7 percent as a decimal? Well, if we have a number that’s written as a percent but we want to write it as a decimal instead, then we take that number written as a percent, divide it by 100 percent, and our answer will be that value written as a decimal. So then in our case, we’ll take 2.7 percent and divide it by 100 percent, which gives us the result 0.027. That’s 2.7 percent written as a decimal.

It’s that value that we’ll plug in for the efficiency 𝐸 in our equation. And we’re now ready to calculate UPO, the useful power output, of this incandescent bulb. When we multiply these two numbers together and then round our answer to two significant figures, like we’re asked, we get a result of 4.1 watts. This helps clarify just how inefficient an incandescent light bulb is. Of the 150 watts we used to power it, only 4.1 of those watts are useful power output. This is a big part of the reason why incandescent light bulbs are often replaced with higher-efficiency LEDs. Let’s move on to considering the cost of operating these two different types of bulbs.

The LED light has a greater efficiency than the incandescent light bulb. How does the efficiency of the new light affect the cost of using the light? Give a reason for your answer.

So in this case, we’re comparing these two types of bulbs on the basis of their efficiency, that is, how much useful power output they have for total power input. We saw in the earlier example that the efficiency of an incandescent bulb is somewhere around three percent. On the other hand, the efficiency of an LED bulb is roughly 80 percent, many times more than the incandescent. This means that, for the LED bulb, about 80 percent of the power that we put in we get out as useful power output, that is, light.

Let’s say that we wanted to get the same amount of light from each one of these bulbs, the incandescent and the LED. In order to do that, the power that we would need to put into the incandescent bulb would be much greater than the power we would need to put into the LED. That’s because of their differences in efficiency. That electrical power comes at a cost, a monetary cost, and that’s what our question focuses on. It says, “How does the difference in efficiencies of these two bulbs affect their cost of operation?”

Here’s what we can write about that. We can say that the cost of using the LED bulb is lower than the cost of using the incandescent bulb because less energy is wasted as heat. For an equal bulb brightness, that is, an equal useful power output for the two bulbs, the LED bulb generates much less heat than the incandescent one. In other words, it’s less wasteful, and therefore its cost of operation is lower.

Nagwa uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more about our Privacy Policy.